Aug 05, 20 hi, i uses both nagios and zabbix but i would like to vote in favor of zabbix due to following reasons. Nagios has a long history, and a lot of resistance to changing what makes it difficult. I have a tomcat in which i have deployed 3 war files. Zabbix vs nagios vs pandora fms comparative in depth. I am pretty comfortable with nagios and a newbie in zabbix. I was an nagios but then change to zabbix becouse of the map creation feature out of the box and the windows and linux native clients. Nagios feels like a mishmash of parts from many different toolmakers. Once implemented we have options to generate reports for host, host group on time range of hour, day, week, month, year.
Compare real user opinions on the pros and cons to make more informed decisions. We know that many corporative installations nowadays use nagios as their main monitoring system for networks, systems and applications. Zabbix vs nagios comparison software architect kristof kovacs. While it could benefit greatly from a moderated zabbix community, its support from the open source community has filled the whole rather well. When looking for a complete comparison of the differences between zabbix vs nagios, there are some basic functions that we need that we need to take into account and understand why they. While their api goes part of the way in solving this problem, it doesnt provide the full control that simple. As you can imagine, graphs are a very useful way to view data because they can show historical information in an easy to view manner. Two of such network monitoring tools are zabbix and nagios. On the other hand it sounds like zabbix is a more complete solution and easier to configure than either of the other two. Zabbix can actually employ nagios addons with a little manual scripting to adapt the output of functions from the nagios architecture to the more simplistic information flow procedures of zabbix.
With our live, virtual training, you can interact with our instructors as they walk you through nagios. It enables users to compare files, directories plus version controlled programs. Zabbix is good for what it does, but if you want to automate creation of hosts i. Nagios and learn how to successfully install, configure and manage a nagios deployment. Nagios, zabbix and pandora fms comparison victormadrid. Nagios can produce many of the same types of graphs, but only via thirdparty addons and external. Both of these tools have made it into our top network monitoring software page and are all around great tools for those looking for an opensource network monitoring solution anyone that has to manage systems for a living should always be looking to innovate. With zabbix, you can store nearly all data in your db, and query it at any time you want.
The latter gets its configuration from etc nagios g. Manual provides all necessary information to successfully install, configure, and run zabbix. Zabbix vs nagios comparison software architect kristof. Nagios does not ship with log monitoring, though it is. I came from nagios and cactii too and had tried zabbix, but didnt stick.
When looking for a complete comparison of the differences between zabbix vs nagios, there are some basic functions that we need that we need to take into account and understand why they are necessary for a network monitoring solution. When i read your comment that zabbix took a lot of point and click to start, i realized i wasnt alone and gave it. Or you already know nagios but you are not happy with it and are looking for nagios alternatives. Built specifically for developers, it comes with the. This article is the continuation of our ongoing series about linux top tools, in this series we will introduce you most famous open source tools for linux systems with the increase in use of portable document format. Hi, i uses both nagios and zabbix but i would like to vote in favor of zabbix due to following reasons. Zabbix vs nagios top 8 essential differences of zabbix. Choose business it software and services with confidence. With our live, virtual training, you can interact with our instructors as they walk you through nagios labs to help you really get the hang of our software suite. When i read your comment that zabbix took a lot of point and click to start, i realized i wasnt alone and gave it another try.
The nagios nrpeplugin package needs to be installed on the nagios server, and nagios nrpeserver on the hosts where local tests need to run. Zabbix vs nagios comparison for network and bandwidth. We do, however, think these community contributions are pretty damn cool. I set it up in one day and never make any other change i think im loosing some good features that could leran if read more for me is great and makes forget nagios.
Nagios vs zabbix compared which is better for network. Zabbix feels like a system made by a single toolmaker with a vision. The same general scope differences as in the case of nagios apply here. Zabbix had the best support for the devices i initially had in my network, its ability to adapt and change has made it my swiss army knife of monitoring tools. Recebe, processa e persiste armazena os dados agente. And thanks alot guys, i really appreciate all of your advice. Here is a practical comparison of nagios vs zabbix. Hi i have just built my zabbix server and in the process of configuring some checks currently setup in nagios. Zabbix vs nagios comparison for network and bandwidth monitoring.
Those here that are mocking zabbix and saying nagios is the real scalable monitor are stuck in the past. Sensu is a composable monitoring pipeline that can reuse existing nagios checks. Several tools are available to help with network monitoring, from open source applications to those that require commercial licenses. I have no experience with manin, but cacti seemed to work better with network devices think cisco n stuff, zabbix is much better. Whilst both zabbix and pandora fms have a webbased management interface, nagios has decided to keep it old school, and is still managed through a complex maze of text files, scripts and manual procedures that also make a necessity to use third party tools in order to deploy it, such as chef or puppet.
The zabbix tool can be categorized into the monitoring application which is available as opensource that used for monitoring the performance of vms virtual machine, networks and servers and also capable of monitoring cpu utilization, network utilization and disk consumption on machines. I think nagios pay more attention on the net architecture, while zabbix is emphasized on. Grafana is a general purpose dashboard and graph composer. It is web based but gives the flexibility to use api and working with api is quiet easy.
The debate between zabbix vs nagios is a topic that comes up quite often between it professionals, and the subject is valid. It is web based but gives the flexibility to use api and working with api is. I also use a third, much simpler system to monitor the main monitoring system. Zabbix vs nagios comparison, which is better for network. Application level monitoring in tomcat using zabbixnagios. The zabbix system can place a heavy load on the operating system. As it stands right now, it seems that i would have to have two copies of almost every host in my environment as there would be one for the discovered vmware virtual machine and another one for the data pulled by the installed agent. The company is on a merge and sectors are being discarded it is quite a. As industry experts and the creators of nagios core the most widely used opensource monitoring project in the world we believe our product prices reflect where the industrys pricing should be. Fast forward a year later and now the powers that be want to try the managed services route again. Both of these programs have free opensource version available to download and install in your networks. Change directory and create directory inside zabbixdynamicpdfreport. Nagios enterprises makes no claims or warranties as to the fitness of any file or information on this website, for any purpose whatsoever. I am able to monitor the tomcat as such using nagios but i am not able to monitor the individual status of the 3 applications.
Nagios sets itself up as the industry standard in it infrastructure monitoring while zabbix says it is the enterpriseclass monitoring solution for everyone. Repository of templates, addons and modules for zabbix. For years, i was using nagios for server monitoring, but now im in the process of switching to zabbix. Nowadays its not uncommon for companies to use nagios as their main monitoring tool for networks, systems and. Its focused on providing rich ways to visualize time series metrics, mainly though graphs but supports other ways to visualize data through a pluggable panel architectur. Zabbix has been designed to scale from small environments with a few devices to. Im seeing they all basically do the same things with varying degrees of setup pain in the ass.
One distinctive difference between nagios and zabbix is the outofbox availability of graphs in zabbix but the lack thereof in nagios. All zabbix agents should be configured and initialized by the zabbix server at first, then they can be aware of what types of metrics they should collect, how long the metering intervals should. Monitoring is not so easy with nagios as one has to deal with hundreds of custom scripts when made another user it almost become some sort of enigma to decode. As industry experts and the creators of nagios core the most widely used opensource monitoring project in the world we believe our product prices reflect where the. Centreon is most compared with zabbix, nagios xi and nagios core, whereas zabbix is most compared with centreon, splunk and icinga. I am able to monitor the tomcat as such using nagios but i am not able. Zabbix has better reporting built in, particularly regarding performance data and trending.
Can anyone explain what this check means in nagios and how i can replicate it in zabbix. Ive spent the morning reading comparisons on spiceworks, nagios. I have no experience with manin, but cacti seemed to work better with network devices think cisco n stuff, zabbix is much better in allaround os and application level monitoring. I think nagios pay more attention on the net architecture, while zabbix is emphasized on os itself. Repository of templates, addons and modules for zabbix repository of templates, addons and modules for zabbix. Your company needs a network monitoring tool but you are still comparing solutions, especially prtg network monitor vs nagios. These pages are created to help users successfully manage their monitoring tasks with zabbix, from the simple to the more complex. Also, as we mentioned in the article on the best network monitoring tools, zabbix has been taking pieces from nagios cake for a long time. I also use a third, much simpler system to monitor the main. Feb 20, 2016 depends on what would you like to achieve.
This file should list the tests that can be started remotely, and the ip addresses of the machines allowed to trigger them. Ive spent the morning reading comparisons on spiceworks, nagios, zabbix, cactus and others i cant recall at the moment. From what i have read a lot of people tend to use munin and nagios together munin for history and graphs, and nagios for alerting. Finally, the nagios community is huge, more chance of finding an issue already explained, an uncommon check already written, tons of docs, etc. Nagios xi vs zabbix monitoring solution 2020 feature and. To add items, data of which are to be displayed in the graph, click on add in the items block, select items and then set attributes for the way item data will be displayed item display attributes. Zabbix is a solid project with a complex and modular architecture, that has grown throughout time with a design directed by the team of architects itself. Zabbix can display your info in enough different ways to satisfy most requirements. As it stands right now, it seems that i would have to have two copies of almost every host in my environment as there would be one for the discovered vmware virtual machine and another. Guidance on installation and configuration of a zabbix. Is it possible to individually monitor those applications using nagios zabbix. Hi i have just built my zabbix server and in the process of. Nagios can produce many of the same types of graphs, but only via thirdparty addons and external tools. However, the zabbix community is a great source of templates, which is the main method available to customize zabbix.
13 457 978 1015 1525 1657 1312 111 1011 1031 281 1259 1140 921 710 840 352 238 1071 1003 478 1009 843 422 1177 1432 1095 500 855 268 912 1603 791 1642 638 785 580 416 1446 1422 801 1384 862 1116 622 978 428 203